Author Archives: admin

Extended Consultation Period

Following complaints from AG RAG that many of our members did not receive the promised invitation to the public exhibition, and the very short notice of the even given, Defence Estates has agreed to allow an extra week for people to submit their comments on the proposals.

The exhibition is open tonight until 8pm and from 8am to 2pm tomorrow. The plans are also available online at http://dataroom.gvagrimley.co.uk/arborfield/.

BBC and ITV Ejected from Exhibition

The public exhibition is now open in the community centre. We were pleased that a crew from BBC South were able to attend and report on the exhibition.

However it is a disappointment that despite this being a public exhibition, and the many statements about welcoming public comment representatives of Defence Estates asked the BBC reporter to leave and denied ITV permission to film at all because the exhibition was being held on an MoD site.

Look out for the report on BBC South tonight.

Public Consultation Newsletter

The following is a copy of the newsletter that we have been distributing outside the short notice public consultation and exhibition that the Defence Estates consortium represented by GVA Grimley are holding today and tomorrow at the Garrison Community Centre.

If you are unable to attend the exhibition or, are like many who did not receive the invites local residents were promised and therefore didn’t know about the event, we have been told by GVA Grimley that the content of the exhibition will be online at http://dataroom.gvagrimley.co.uk/arborfield along with an opportunity to comment. Hopefully that site will be posted more reliably than the invitations to local residents have been.

Fact Lie Sheet Final

Latest Update

The AG-RAG Steering Group would like to bring you up to date on the latest news re the development plans for Arborfield:

1. The MOD are pressing ahead with development proposals

As you may have seen in the press and heard on the radio this week, the MOD announced they intend submitting a formal Planning Application to Wokingham Borough Council in January 2011 to starting building a huge new development in Arborfield in 2011. It will not be finished until 2026.

2. The size of the proposed development and the loss of scores of acres of green fields is totally unacceptable

While AG-RAG accept the need for some new houses and would support a suitably sized development on brown field land if/when the MOD have physically left the garrison site itself, we remain vehemently opposed to the scale of the proposed development and to the loss of huge swathes of green fields, open spaces and sport pitches all around us.

3. There is still complete uncertainty as to whether the MOD will stay in Arborfield or move out

Although the plans to move to South Wales have been axed, it’s still not clear if the MOD will remain in Arborfield or move elsewhere. AG-RAG’s firm view is that until the MOD have not only said they will leave the site (after all, they’ve been saying for the last 20+ years that they would be leaving), but they have actually left it and switched all the lights off, that no development should start. Otherwise, residents could be left with the worst of all worlds – a huge new development, our green fields and open spaces gone, the MOD still on site, and insufficient profit generated by the developers to enable them to fund improvements to the roads, sewage, water and other infrastructure required to support all the new houses and cars.

4. Public Exhibition

The MOD will be holding a public exhibition on in the Garrison Community Centre (off Princess Marina Drive) on Thursday 9 December between 12 mid-day & 8pm and on Friday 10 December between 8am & 2pm. They have told us that they have sent letters to each household in the area inviting you to the exhibition, although we know many of these letters have not yet arrived.

5. AG-RAG Believes the Exhibition Will Be Misleading

AG-RAG has seen an early draft of some of the exhibition material and believe it highly misleading. For a start, if the MOD really wanted to hear the views of all local residents, the exhibition should have been held over several days, including a week end, and not during 1 1/2 working days. Furthermore, the MOD will only be talking about the development on the land they own around Arborfield. Another consortium will be submitting a separate Planning Application for the land they own (essentially from Hogwood up to near where the Community Centre is).

6. AG-RAG Fact Sheet

Because of the misleading nature of the exhibition, the AG-RAG Steering Group is preparing a fact sheet to counter the MOD’s claims. We plan to hand out a copy of this factsheet to everyone who goes to the exhibition. YOU could help us please by giving up an hour (or more) of your time to hand out the newsletters. If you can help please let me know the hour timeslot(s) you could hand the newsletters out.

6. It’s Crucial YOU make your views known

The MOD are giving residents until Friday 7 January 2011 to make our views known. It’s crucial that you make your objections and other comments known to the MOD by this date.

So, in summary, the MOD are pushing ahead with their plans for a huge new development which the vast majority of Arborfield residents do not want, need or support. We believe NO development should start until the MOD has not only said they they will leave the site but that they have physically left it! Even then, no development should start on green fields and other open spaces until the brown field land where the existingh army buildings are, has been exhausted. AG-RAG believes the exhibition later this week is meant to mislead us so we are preparing a fact sheet with the true situation. You can help by not only making your views known to the MOD but by sparing an hour of your time to hand leaflets out to those people who go to the exhibition.

Thanks & Regards,

Martin Rutter

Chairman, Arborfield Garrison – Residents Action Group

IMPORTANT UPDATE: Public Consultation

In the recent press release from Wokingham Borough Council where the council announced that they were pushing ahead with the Arborfield Garrison SDL after “a firm commitment” from the MoD (actually a letter from Defence Estates – the Army requirements are still under review and will not be known before the spring) the council highlighted that they were expecting outline planning applications for the whole of the SDL in the new year.

As part of this process the main consortium representing Defence Estates, the landowners of Dovecot Nursery and Westwood Farm are intending to mount a public exhibition and consultation in order to show local residents their plans for the site and get their feedback. GVA Grimley have been appointed by the consortium to prepare and co-ordinate the submission of the planning application.

1500 residents will get invites by letter to attend shortly, but we at AG-RAG feel that the consultation and exhibition are being deliberately timed such that there will be the minimum response from residents. We however feel that as many people as possible should be able to attend and let the developers know exactly what they think of their plans.

The exhibition will be held at the Arborfield Garrison Community Centre on Thursday 9th and Friday 10th December (yes that is next week). The exhibition will be open from 12pm to 8pm on the Thursday and from 8am to 2pm on the Friday. Consortium representatives will be on site to answer questions and take your feedback in person.

If you can’t make the exhibition (and we know many cannot) the consortium will put their proposals on a website at www.gvagrimley.co.uk/consultarborfield from Thursday 9th December onwards, and will be accepting e-mail responses at consult.arborfield@gvagrimley.co.uk up to Friday 7th January 2011.

We cannot stress how important it is to participate in this consultation – it is your one opportunity to speak directly to the developer consortium before the formal planning application processes commence in the new year, and to see in detail what they have planned for our community.

Martin on Radio Reading 107FM

Yesterday Martin recorded an interview with Radio Reading 107FM talking about the most recent developments with the Arborfield Garrison SDL, and also talking a bit about the background to the development. Here we present the full interview, our thanks to the team at Radio Reading 107FM for supplying us with a copy of the recording.
Arborfield Garrison Residents Action Group On Radio Reading 107Fm by Martin Rutter (Arborfield Garrison Residents Action Group)
Download now or listen on posterous

Arborfield Garrison Residents Action Group on Radio Reading 107FM.mp3 (10557 KB)

An Update from Martin

With all that has happened this week, our chairman Martin Rutter has today e-mailed the following message to all our members.

To: All members of the Arborfield Garrsion Residents Action Group

Does the left hand know what the right hand is doing?!

Dear All,

Following the dramatic events of the last few days, the AG-RAG Steering Group thought we’d update you on the latest situation:

The Government’s Defence Review Announcement – Great News for Us!

We were all pretty elated on Tuesday when the government announced as part of the Defence Review that they were scrapping plans for the new tripartite forces training academy in South Wales, and that Arborfield Garrison was to remain open. We even heard from a source inside the Garrison who was present at the briefing given there on Tuesday morning, that Arborfield could take some of the overspill of personnel from other sites.

This seemed to us that the Arborfield SDL was dead in the water and we could finally celebrate that the rural feel and tranquility of Arborfield had been saved!!

Wokingham Borough Council’s Special executive Meeting on 21/10/10 – More Good News for Us!

Our joy was made even sweeter at the WBC Exec meeting on Thursday night where AG-RAG had pre-submitted 10 written questions to the Exec. Before we could ask some of them, Gary Cowan proposed the following amendment to the recommendation already placed before the Exec:

I propose that the Arborfield Master Plan is deferred until the Secretary of State for Defence can confirm the date when the site will become fully vacant and that date must be such that the planned development can be accommodated within the remaining Core Strategy plan period to 2026.

In addition some changes to the Arborfield Masterplan are materially different to those consulted on as it fails to take note of the extensive consultation comments submitted by residents and other representative groups which are supported by the many questions submitted this evening.

These issues are not properly reflected in tonight’s amended Masterplan and the report under analysis of issues, appendix A, or the accompanying map and for that reason I would also propose that the Masterplan is also reviewed to properly reflect these issues.

Gary’s amendment was accepted unanimously by the Executive. At long last, and at the 11th hour and 59th minute, WBC finally appeared to have listened to the views, comments, complaints and objections that we’d been making for many months, and deferred the Masterplan for Arborfield. So surely that was the final nail in the Arborfield SDL coffin for at least the next several years.

But NO, Just When We Thought It Was All Over!

We have received the following e-mail from the Defence Estates who are acting on behalf of the MOD in terms of land sale etc.

Hi Martin, as you will be aware from previous MoD correspondence, irrespective of the DTR decision it still remains MoDs intention under contingency plans to dispose of the Garrison as has consistently been the message at/since the Core Strategy EiP last year.

I understand in the light of last nights WBC Executive meeting, that MoD will be writing to WBC to confirm their latest position. Further, we remain instructed to submit an outline planning application (in January 2011) including redevelopment of the whole Garrison site.

Kind regards
Roger

Roger Shipton – Associate, Planning Development & Regeneration
For and behalf of GVA Grimley Ltd

I’ve spoken with Gary Cowan about this and his view is that we shouldn’t be too worried by the e-mail. He believes the Defence Estates are simply forward looking to try and set a price for the land for some time in the future.

But, it’s clear the MOD & Defence Estates are still working to sell / develop the land, so the message to everyone in the AG-RAG and in Arborfield Garrison, is that the fight still isn’t over!

Best wishes,
Martin Rutter
Chairman, AG-RAG
07885 339772

Latest Update

Over the past few days we have been distributing our latest newsletter updating everybody on the current status of our campaign. The newsletter has been delivered to the majority of houses in the southern part of Arborfield.

The key point to take on board is that whilst the election of a new government has put a hold on the building plans from Wokingham Borough Council, this is only temporary, the council still has to build some new homes, even if not in the same volumes as were previously envisaged. Also as the recent news from Shinfield shows, the various developer groupings are carrying on regardless – we expect a public consultation followed by a planning application from the consortium representing the MoD and local landowners for the Arborfield Garrison SDL later in the year. This is all despite the fact that the current spending review calls into question whether the Garrison will even close at all.

An electronic copy of the newsletter can be seen below.

Letters to Westminster

On Friday we posted the following letters addressed to the Prime Minister, Deputy Prime Minister and Secretary of State for Defence, reminding them of the commitments in both the Conservative and Liberal Democrat manifesto documents, that are now reflected in the coalition document with regards to the Regional Spatial Strategy. We also highlight the need for a clear decision on Arborfield Garrison from the Secretary of State.

We also found out on Friday that the special Executive Meeting, scheduled for 3rd June has now been cancelled, due to the “unavailability of Executive Members”. The decisions on the masterplan documents have now been postponed until the next full executive meeting scheduled for 24th June.

The letters we have sent can be seen below:

Open Letter to Prime Minister 28 May 2010 [Final]

Open Letter to Deputy Prime Minister 28 May 2010 [Final]

Open Letter to SoS for Defence 28 May 2010 (Final)

Wokingham Borough Council Executive Date Change and Other Important Dates

You may have noticed on our recent newsletter that the date of the Wokingham Borough Council Executive meeting at which the Executive will discuss our responses to the Strategic Development Location Masterplans has changed – it will now be held on 3rd June, at 7:30pm at Shute End. Please note the date as this is a vital meeting at which to make our presence felt as this is when the governing executive make the decision as to whether to adopt the masterplan document.

As local residents we are each entitled to ask a question of the executive, which includes our own newly re-elected councillor Gary Cowan, so it is important that we take this opportunity. If you need a reminder of the promises that Gary made during the election, they can be found in his campaign literature.

As both the Conservative and Liberal Democrat national manifesto documents included promises to abolish the regional housing targets that were being blamed for the scale of building at Arborfield, it was no surprise that the coalition document contained the promise to return planning on housing matters to local authorities – see section 4 of the document. As such, our local executive will soon be the ultimate decision making body on how much house building occurs and where it is built, therefore it is important that we make our feelings clear about building at Arborfield.

Other important dates to note are 25th May, at 7:30pm at the Village Hall, which is the twice postponed parish meeting. Again this is an opportunity to ask our Parish Councillors what they are doing to influence the building plans for Arborfield.

We are also gathering at 6:30pm on Friday 28th May for a photo call with our local newspapers as we post letters to David Cameron, Nick Clegg, Eric Pickles (the Secretary of State for Communities) and Liam Fox (the Secretary of State for Defence), to urge them to quickly implement the promise to abolish the regional housing plans, and also to ask what they intend to do with Arborfield in the newly announce Defence Spending Review. We would like as many people as possible to be present for the photo call.