Category Archives: Comment

Defence Estates Consortium and the Bypass

If you read the Wokingham Times you will see that on page three of the 18th January issue they have picked up on the comment that the MoD backed Defence Estates Consortium are unwilling to fund a bypass for Arborfield, instead suggesting that modifications to the existing roundabout would be adequate to mitigate the traffic effects. Of course this is contrary to the published traffic modelling which can be found on the Wokingham Borough Council site. The Forecast Year Results report  contains three scenarios, the first being to build no houses, the second to build houses with no mitigating work, and the third to build everything proposed in the planning documents including a bypass for Arborfield. The report makes the following conclusion in paragraph 4.4.2:

It has not been possible to demonstrate that an absolute nil detriment position has been reached through a comparison of Scenarios C and A. However,the introduction of off-site infrastructure reduces the impact of SDL development proposals on travel through Wokingham demonstrated through the assessment of ten travel time routes across the Borough. This results in a 9% increase in travel time on these routes in the AM peak period and a 5% increase in the PM peak period. Furthermore there is a clear benefit through adoption of the infrastructure associated with Scenario C demonstrated through the comparison between Scenarios C and B.

Essentially we’re told that unpublished MoD modelling indicates that a new road in unnecessary, but the published report concludes that even if every road scheme is built the required nil detriment position will not be achieved. So who do you think is right, the published report, or the secret MoD modelling that nobody has seen?

As our contribution to the article we issued the following statement to the press:

U-turn Final PDF

Arborfield SDL Adoption – Special Executive Meeting

If you submitted any comments to the recent re-consultation you should have received notification late last week of the special executive meeting called by Wokingham Borough Council on this coming Wednesday, 5th October at 7pm in the Council Chamber at which they propose to adopt the four revised Strategic Development Location documents. Despite all their comments to consult more fully, the council is again calling a meeting at less than a weeks notice.

Whilst we know it is short notice, members of AG-RAG are encouraged to attend the meeting if at all possible. As with other executive meetings questions can only be asked in advance in writing using the form linked from this page on the council web site. Each person is only allowed to ask one question, but if they are at the meeting in person can ask a supplementary question. If a questioner is absent then the question will be asked and answered. The answers will be sent to questioners in writing whether they attend the meeting or not.

If you are happy to ask one of the questions that AG-RAG would like to ask please contact us using the form on this site, if you have your own question please let us know what you are planning to ask to ensure that we don’t ‘waste’ a question by asking one that is similar to one that is already being asked.

If you need any more guidance, the following document covers our main points of contention with the SDL document as it stands.

Main Points From AGRAG

This may well be your last opportunity before the planning applications start coming in to ask questions and influence the masterplanning process, once the plan is adopted any planning applications will be assessed against the adopted plan so our ability to object to aspects of the development will be severely curtailed. We would therefore urge you not to miss out on this last chance.

As the Consultation Closes, What Have People Written?

Today what is potentially the final consultation on the Arborfield Garrison SDL closed.

Firstly our thanks go to everybody who has contributed to the consultation, we can only hope that our views will be considered and acted upon by Wokingham Borough Council. We’d also like to thank the volunteers around Arborfield and the neighbouring villages who spent time delivering flyers and knocking on doors getting the word out about the consultation, sadly the Borough Council’s attempts to notify people consisting of newspaper advertisements, and an article buried away on page 18 of a council publication that in the case of Arborfield didn’t even reach residents until the consultation was almost over was not overly successful in getting the message out judging by the number of comments we’ve received from people who only found out through our posters and flyers.

As we move forward, the usual method by which Wokingham Borough Council releases details of the consultation responses is by means of a summary document, often this groups responses into broad categories, and often the text of the letters is reduced to a sentence or two. Whilst Wokingham Borough Council will give a number of reasons as to why they do this, it does serve to hide away the sometimes strong feelings that local residents have expressed in their letters. However, with the permission of the the writers, we have posted some examples of the letters people have written on a special page. If you wish to share your letter too, please contact us and forward us a copy of your letter and we will post it there.

Our sincere thanks go to those people who have agreed to share their letters with us and a wider audience.

A Garrison Resident who Can’t Write to Wokingham Borough Council

Here is a picture snapped earlier today of a Garrison resident who has no voice, and cannot write and comment on Wokingham Borough Council’s plan to bulldoze over green fields at Arborfield Garrison. The picture was taken from Tyler Drive, looking into land that under the plans would disappear under houses along with many more acres of land to the south of the garrison. As residents will tell you, deer are quite a common sight crossing these fields currently – they won’t be when Wokingham Borough Council and their developers are finished with the area.

Also living around the area are badgers – with previous developments having had to take special account of their presence. You can also often see bats flying around the area at dusk.

Time is fast running out on what is expected to be the final consultation on the plans. With the council ruling out any extension to the consultation period the deadline for interested parties to submit their comments is next week, on the 27th July. You can find details of the council plans and details of how to submit comments on our recent post about the re-consultation.

Make your voice heard, before it is too late.

Defence Transformation Announcement

Yesterday Dr Liam Fox, announced details of the Defence Transformation. Whilst the newspapers are concentrating on other aspects, part of his statement directly affects us in Arborfield.

“RAF Lyneham is the preferred location for future defence technical training. This confirms that the Department will withdraw from Arborfield in Berkshire and Bordon in Hampshire, releasing the sites for sale by 2014-15 at the latest.”

However the statement says later that detailed planning work has yet to start and the dates might change, and of course RAF Lyneham was in the process of closing (due to be completed in 2012), hence why repatriations moved to RAF Brize Norton recently, which once again highlights that MoD plans change.

Therefore it is vitally important that as many people as possible get their comments into the ongoing Wokingham Borough Council consultation by 27th July. Aside from the many specific issues with the plan, with Wokingham councillors again talking about the certainty of the decision to move we need to highlight that MoD plans change, RAF Lyneham being a prime example, and therefore they cannot assume that the MoD will leave until they have actually gone.

Expect congestion at Barkham Bridge

The photograph below shows Barkham Bridge taken on a quiet Sunday morning. A single carriageway bridge on the edge of Arborfield on the main road between Arborfield to Wokingham. Any takers on what the traffic is normally like on this road in rush hour? Any thoughts on what it would be like with a potential extra 7,000 cars in the area?

Residents need to be aware that the SDL planning as it stands does not include any provision for upgrade of this bridge at Barkham or on the other side of Aborfield roads through Eversley.

Single Carriageway Bridge at Barkahm

Martin on Radio Reading 107FM

Yesterday Martin recorded an interview with Radio Reading 107FM talking about the most recent developments with the Arborfield Garrison SDL, and also talking a bit about the background to the development. Here we present the full interview, our thanks to the team at Radio Reading 107FM for supplying us with a copy of the recording.
Arborfield Garrison Residents Action Group On Radio Reading 107Fm by Martin Rutter (Arborfield Garrison Residents Action Group)
Download now or listen on posterous

Arborfield Garrison Residents Action Group on Radio Reading 107FM.mp3 (10557 KB)

An Update from Martin

With all that has happened this week, our chairman Martin Rutter has today e-mailed the following message to all our members.

To: All members of the Arborfield Garrsion Residents Action Group

Does the left hand know what the right hand is doing?!

Dear All,

Following the dramatic events of the last few days, the AG-RAG Steering Group thought we’d update you on the latest situation:

The Government’s Defence Review Announcement – Great News for Us!

We were all pretty elated on Tuesday when the government announced as part of the Defence Review that they were scrapping plans for the new tripartite forces training academy in South Wales, and that Arborfield Garrison was to remain open. We even heard from a source inside the Garrison who was present at the briefing given there on Tuesday morning, that Arborfield could take some of the overspill of personnel from other sites.

This seemed to us that the Arborfield SDL was dead in the water and we could finally celebrate that the rural feel and tranquility of Arborfield had been saved!!

Wokingham Borough Council’s Special executive Meeting on 21/10/10 – More Good News for Us!

Our joy was made even sweeter at the WBC Exec meeting on Thursday night where AG-RAG had pre-submitted 10 written questions to the Exec. Before we could ask some of them, Gary Cowan proposed the following amendment to the recommendation already placed before the Exec:

I propose that the Arborfield Master Plan is deferred until the Secretary of State for Defence can confirm the date when the site will become fully vacant and that date must be such that the planned development can be accommodated within the remaining Core Strategy plan period to 2026.

In addition some changes to the Arborfield Masterplan are materially different to those consulted on as it fails to take note of the extensive consultation comments submitted by residents and other representative groups which are supported by the many questions submitted this evening.

These issues are not properly reflected in tonight’s amended Masterplan and the report under analysis of issues, appendix A, or the accompanying map and for that reason I would also propose that the Masterplan is also reviewed to properly reflect these issues.

Gary’s amendment was accepted unanimously by the Executive. At long last, and at the 11th hour and 59th minute, WBC finally appeared to have listened to the views, comments, complaints and objections that we’d been making for many months, and deferred the Masterplan for Arborfield. So surely that was the final nail in the Arborfield SDL coffin for at least the next several years.

But NO, Just When We Thought It Was All Over!

We have received the following e-mail from the Defence Estates who are acting on behalf of the MOD in terms of land sale etc.

Hi Martin, as you will be aware from previous MoD correspondence, irrespective of the DTR decision it still remains MoDs intention under contingency plans to dispose of the Garrison as has consistently been the message at/since the Core Strategy EiP last year.

I understand in the light of last nights WBC Executive meeting, that MoD will be writing to WBC to confirm their latest position. Further, we remain instructed to submit an outline planning application (in January 2011) including redevelopment of the whole Garrison site.

Kind regards
Roger

Roger Shipton – Associate, Planning Development & Regeneration
For and behalf of GVA Grimley Ltd

I’ve spoken with Gary Cowan about this and his view is that we shouldn’t be too worried by the e-mail. He believes the Defence Estates are simply forward looking to try and set a price for the land for some time in the future.

But, it’s clear the MOD & Defence Estates are still working to sell / develop the land, so the message to everyone in the AG-RAG and in Arborfield Garrison, is that the fight still isn’t over!

Best wishes,
Martin Rutter
Chairman, AG-RAG
07885 339772

Latest Update

Over the past few days we have been distributing our latest newsletter updating everybody on the current status of our campaign. The newsletter has been delivered to the majority of houses in the southern part of Arborfield.

The key point to take on board is that whilst the election of a new government has put a hold on the building plans from Wokingham Borough Council, this is only temporary, the council still has to build some new homes, even if not in the same volumes as were previously envisaged. Also as the recent news from Shinfield shows, the various developer groupings are carrying on regardless – we expect a public consultation followed by a planning application from the consortium representing the MoD and local landowners for the Arborfield Garrison SDL later in the year. This is all despite the fact that the current spending review calls into question whether the Garrison will even close at all.

An electronic copy of the newsletter can be seen below.

Candidate Statements from the Meeting

We received candidate statements from Gary Cowan standing as our Conservative candidate, and from Steve Bacon standing as our Liberal Democrat candidate. Unfortunately Joan Huntley our candidate from the UK Independence Party has been taken seriously ill and was therefore unable to provide a statement. We wish her a speedy recovery.

The two above statements were read out at the meeting tonight. We would like to thank Gary and Steve for taking the time to prepare and submit their statements.

We would also like to thank Councillor David Lee leader of the council for attending and taking questions from the floor, and to Steve Bacon, Prue Bray the Liberal Democrat PPC, Ann Zebedee the UKIP PPC and Robin Smith an Independent PPC for making time to join us at the meeting.